The short version is that a disallowance letter converts your ERC claim from a waiting problem into a deadline problem. The IRS issued disallowances in waves through 2024–2026 — moratorium-era risk screens, OBBBA-barred Q3–Q4 2021 claims, and eligibility determinations of wildly varying quality. Whatever the reason on your letter, the response framework is the same.

What the letter actually does

Letter 105-C (full disallowance) or 106-C (partial) is the IRS’s formal claim denial. From its date, IRC § 6532(a) gives you two years to file a refund suit in federal district court or the Court of Federal Claims. The only way to extend it is Form 907, a written agreement the IRS must sign — not a phone call, not a pending appeal, not a promise from an agent.

The three paths, honestly compared

Appeals protest: free, often worthwhile on the merits — but it runs on the IRS’s timeline while your two-year clock keeps ticking. Form 907 extension: the insurance policy that makes a long Appeals process safe; request it early, because the IRS doesn’t volunteer it. Refund suit: the only move that takes the decision away from the agency that just denied you — and as we cover in the settlement advantage, most filed cases resolve by negotiation with DOJ Tax, not trial. The full decision framework is in administrative path vs. litigation.

If a PEO filed your claim

The letter likely went to the PEO, the two-year clock is running against the PEO’s claim, and in most cases only the PEO can sue. That makes getting documentation and cooperation from the PEO urgent — the demand list is in ERC refunds and PEOs.

What to do this week

Calendar the letter date plus two years, minus a safety margin. Pull your claim file together — the 941-X, the eligibility workpapers, whoever prepared them. Then decide the path with counsel: our ERC litigation practice handles disallowance responses through suit and settlement, and the refund tracker follows the deadlines that govern everyone. Book a free 15-minute call — bring the letter; the date on it is the first thing we’ll read.